
Wisconsin's leaderboard is the opposite of what the population map suggests. Madison holds 12 independent card shops and Green Bay another 9, while Eau Claire — the state's largest city — carries 8. The Fox Valley, not Milwaukee, is where this directory's Wisconsin coverage is thickest.
Statewide there are 173 independents against 36 chain locations, a chain share of only 17%. 8 of the 104 listed cities are chain-only and 64 hold exactly one listing.
Classification runs 152 trading card games to 73 sports cards with 16 under both. Monday closing is unusually common: 56 of the 189 shops with posted hours list Monday as closed, against 45 for Sunday.
Every Wisconsin entry carries an address and a map link; 198 carry a phone number, 189 post hours, and 169 link to a website. 187 have a Google rating attached, which is what the ranking on each list page is built from. Stock, buy prices and event nights are not fields in this dataset, so nothing here can tell you what is in a case today. BMW Sportscards in Madison (5.0 stars from 2,763 reviews), The Crimson Guild in Wauwatosa (5.0 stars from 339 reviews), and Price's Collectibles in Greendale (4.9 stars from 417 reviews) lead the rating-weighted ranking.
Only 42 Wisconsin listings are thin enough to be kept out of search results. 187 of the 209 carry a Google rating and 198 a phone number, both high shares. With the deepest coverage in the Fox Valley rather than Milwaukee, the largest-cities shortcuts at the top of this page are worth reading before the A–Z index below.
Card Shops in Madison, WI
(14 shops)Card Shops in Green Bay, WI
(11 shops)Card Shops in Appleton, WI
(10 shops)
Fox Cities Cards
Sports
BB Sports Cards
Sports



Collecting Haven
SportsCard Shops in Eau Claire, WI
(9 shops)Card Shops in Milwaukee, WI
(8 shops)
Name That Card
Sports

NexGen Cards
TCG
Stevie's SportsCards
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Superior, WI
(5 shops)

Globe News
TCG + Sports
Collector's Connection
TCG + Sports
GemKeep
TCGCard Shops in Waukesha, WI
(5 shops)Card Shops in Baraboo, WI
(4 shops)Card Shops in Marinette, WI
(4 shops)Card Shops in Wausau, WI
(4 shops)Card Shops in Beaver Dam, WI
(3 shops)
GAME ON
TCG
KLCollectLLC
TCGCard Shops in Brookfield, WI
(3 shops)Card Shops in Fond du Lac, WI
(3 shops)
Atlas Gaming
TCG
Card Shops in Kenosha, WI
(3 shops)Card Shops in Menomonee Falls, WI
(3 shops)
Lou's Dugout
Sports
Dans Cards
SportsCard Shops in Monroe, WI
(3 shops)Card Shops in Oconomowoc, WI
(3 shops)Card Shops in Onalaska, WI
(3 shops)Card Shops in Oshkosh, WI
(3 shops)
Cardboard Legacy
Sports
Card Shops in Platteville, WI
(3 shops)
Deals N Dragons
TCG
Platteville Magic and Games
Sports
JayJayBeeTCG
TCGCard Shops in Rhinelander, WI
(3 shops)Card Shops in Fort Atkinson, WI
(2 shops)
Planet Chaos
TCG
Dude's Card Shop
SportsCard Shops in Greenfield, WI
(2 shops)
Brew Town Trading Co
Sports
AJ Collectables
SportsCard Shops in Janesville, WI
(2 shops)
Kryptonite Kollectibles
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Manitowoc, WI
(2 shops)
Stockpile Games
TCGCard Shops in Marshfield, WI
(2 shops)

Card Shops in Menomonie, WI
(2 shops)

Heroes Welcome
TCGCard Shops in Minocqua, WI
(2 shops)

Card Shops in Portage, WI
(2 shops)
Card Shops in Racine, WI
(2 shops)
Card Shops in Rice Lake, WI
(2 shops)
The Boardwalk
TCGCard Shops in Schofield, WI
(2 shops)

Card Shops in Slinger, WI
(2 shops)

Touchdown Sports Cards
SportsCard Shops in Stevens Point, WI
(2 shops)

Larry Fritsch Cards
SportsCard Shops in Stoughton, WI
(2 shops)
Gemini Games
TCG
Nelson Cards
SportsCard Shops in Watertown, WI
(2 shops)

Legend Bros Sports Cards
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Wauwatosa, WI
(2 shops)
Card Shops in West Allis, WI
(2 shops)
Card Shops in West Bend, WI
(2 shops)
Toy Box Toys
TCGCard Shops in Wisconsin Dells, WI
(2 shops)

Elements Boardshop
SportsCard Shops in Ashland, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Birnamwood, WI
(1 shop)
Linton Lane Collectibles
SportsCard Shops in Brandon, WI
(1 shop)
SlabTalk
SportsCard Shops in Butler, WI
(1 shop)
Evolution Gaming
TCGCard Shops in Chippewa Falls, WI
(1 shop)
Spartan Sports Cards & TCG
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Cross Plains, WI
(1 shop)
MadTown Hobby
TCGCard Shops in De Pere, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in DeForest, WI
(1 shop)
Bonsai Cards & Collectibles
SportsCard Shops in Delavan, WI
(1 shop)
Bro Show Collectibles
SportsCard Shops in Dodgeville, WI
(1 shop)
PlayHaven Gaming
TCGCard Shops in Elroy, WI
(1 shop)
skyhigh collectibles
SportsCard Shops in Fennimore, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Franklin, WI
(1 shop)
Game Universe
TCGCard Shops in Glendale, WI
(1 shop)
HoneyBee Games
TCGCard Shops in Greendale, WI
(1 shop)
Price's Collectibles
SportsCard Shops in Hartford, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Hayward, WI
(1 shop)
Muskytown Cards
TCGCard Shops in Hortonville, WI
(1 shop)
Pak Punishers
TCGCard Shops in Hudson, WI
(1 shop)Iconic Sports Cards
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Hustisford, WI
(1 shop)
Kurt's Classics
TCGCard Shops in Kaukauna, WI
(1 shop)
CB Hobby
SportsCard Shops in Lake Mills, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Lake Wissota, WI
(1 shop)
The Retro Garage
TCGCard Shops in Lena, WI
(1 shop)
Cardboard Cash Co.
SportsCard Shops in Lodi, WI
(1 shop)
Mr. Wilson's Card Shop
SportsCard Shops in McFarland, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Medford, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Mequon, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Merrill, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Middleton, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Mosinee, WI
(1 shop)
3D Collectibles
TCGCard Shops in Mukwonago, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Nekoosa, WI
(1 shop)
Mark's Sports Cards
SportsCard Shops in New Franken, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in New Lisbon, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Oak Creek, WI
(1 shop)
Steiny's 7/28 Sports Cards
SportsCard Shops in Pewaukee, WI
(1 shop)
Black Gold Sports Cards
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Reedsburg, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Richfield, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Richland Center, WI
(1 shop)
Baseball Card Shoppe
SportsCard Shops in Ripon, WI
(1 shop)
Hidden Collectibles
SportsCard Shops in Sheboygan, WI
(1 shop)
Victory Games
TCGCard Shops in South Milwaukee, WI
(1 shop)
Pink Bunny Games
TCGCard Shops in Sparta, WI
(1 shop)
Gamers Sanctum
TCGCard Shops in Spring Green, WI
(1 shop)
Moerke Cards
TCGCard Shops in St Croix Falls, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Stanley, WI
(1 shop)
The Hobby Oasis
SportsCard Shops in Sturgeon Bay, WI
(1 shop)
Spuds cards
SportsCard Shops in Sun Prairie, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Tomah, WI
(1 shop)
Jay's Sport and Hobby
SportsCard Shops in Tomahawk, WI
(1 shop)
Card Shops in Twin Lakes, WI
(1 shop)
BS Collectibles
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Verona, WI
(1 shop)
Valhalla Hobby
TCGCard Shops in Waupaca, WI
(1 shop)
Collect Auctions LLC
TCG + SportsCard Shops in Waupun, WI
(1 shop)
Real Sportscards, Wisconsin
SportsCard Shops in Woodruff, WI
(1 shop)
Hawkes Nest
SportsAll Cities in Wisconsin (A–Z)
Chain stores in Wisconsin (36)
National chain locations, listed separately so local shops lead the directory.
- Appleton: GameStop, GameStop
- Baraboo: GameStop + Retro
- Beaver Dam: GameStop
- Beloit: GameStop
- Eau Claire: GameStop
- Fond du Lac: GameStop
- Green Bay: GameStop, GameStop
- Janesville: GameStop
- La Crosse: GameStop
- Lake Geneva: GameStop
- Madison: GameStop, GameStop
- Manitowoc: GameStop
- Marinette: GameStop
- Menomonee Falls: GameStop + Retro
- Milwaukee: GameStop, GameStop, GameStop, GameStop
- Oshkosh: GameStop
- Pleasant Prairie: GameStop + Retro
- Plover: GameStop
- Portage: GameStop
- Racine: GameStop
- Rice Lake: GameStop
- Sheboygan Falls: GameStop + Retro
- Superior: GameStop
- Waukesha: GameStop
- Wausau: GameStop
- Wauwatosa: GameStop
- West Allis: GameStop
- West Bend: GameStop + Retro
- West Milwaukee: GameStop
- Wisconsin Rapids: GameStop
Frequently Asked Questions About Card Shops in Wisconsin
How many card shops are in Wisconsin?
Card Shop Hub lists 173 independent card shops in Wisconsin, across 104 cities, plus 36 national chain locations.
What city in Wisconsin has the most card shops?
Madison has the most, with 14 shops. It is followed by Green Bay (11), Appleton (10), and Eau Claire (9).
Do card shops in Wisconsin sell sports cards or trading card games?
Of the 209 shops listed in Wisconsin, 152 are filed under trading card games and 73 under sports cards. 16 are filed under both and count in each.
Which card shops in Wisconsin are rated highest?
Ranked by customer rating and review volume, the top-rated local shops are BMW Sportscards in Madison (5.0 stars, 2763 reviews), The Crimson Guild in Wauwatosa (5.0 stars, 339 reviews), and Price's Collectibles in Greendale (4.9 stars, 417 reviews).
Own a card shop in Wisconsin? We build card shop websites and hand you the keys — the domain is yours, the files are yours, and there's no monthly bill.
Get a website →Card Shows in Wisconsin
Upcoming card shows in Wisconsin — Show dates, venues, and vendor tables on Card Show Hub.












































