
Herkimer, New York has 3 card shops in our directory — 1 is filed under trading card games and 2 under sports cards. Every listing has an address and a Google Maps link; 2 of 3 also have a phone number and 3 have posted hours.
Of those 3, 2 are independent shops and 1 is a national chain location. Independents are listed first on this page and the chain entry sits in a collapsed block at the end. That makes Herkimer the 18th-largest concentration of independent shops among New York's 146 cities with one. Statewide, New York has 299 independent listings across 146 cities, plus 87 chain locations listed separately. The nearest other cities with shops on file are Utica (2 shops, about 11 miles), Chadwicks (1 shop, about 14 miles), and Yorkville (1 shop, about 15 miles).
Every one of these 3 shops carries a rating; weighting each rating by how many reviews stand behind it puts Paul Carl Cards first, on 5.0 stars across 4 reviews. Looking at the 3 posted schedules here: 2 are open every day of the week, 1 closes on Mondays, and 1 closes on Sundays. All 3 listings carry a website as well as an address, which is better field coverage than most cities this size. Stock, buy prices and event schedules are outside what this directory tracks, so call ahead for anything specific. The shop-finding guide and the starter guide cover the questions worth asking.


Chain stores in Herkimer (1)
National chain locations, listed separately so local shops lead the directory.
- GameStop — 324 E State St
Nearest Cities to Herkimer
Own a card shop in Herkimer, NY? We build card shop websites and hand you the keys — the domain is yours, the files are yours, and there's no monthly bill.
Get a website →Card Shows in New York
Upcoming card shows in New York — Show dates, venues, and vendor tables on Card Show Hub.