Card Shops in Commack, New York

Commack, New York has 4 card shops in our directory — 4 are filed under trading card games and 2 under sports cards; 2 are filed under both and count in each. Every listing has an address and a Google Maps link; 4 of 4 also have a phone number and 4 have posted hours.

3 of the 4 are independent and 1 belongs to a national chain. The chain location is kept out of the main grid and collected at the bottom. Statewide, New York has 253 independent listings across 144 cities, plus 100 chain locations listed separately. Every one of these 4 shops carries a rating; weighting each rating by how many reviews stand behind it puts Cardboard Memories Sports Memorabilia first, on 4.7 stars across 168 reviews. Looking at the 4 posted schedules here: 4 are open every day of the week. 2 of the 4 Commack listings are filed under both trading card games and sports cards, which is why the 4 TCG and 2 sports figures overlap: they add to 6, not 4.

That makes Commack the tenth-largest concentration of independent shops among New York's 144 cities with one. The nearest other cities with shops on file are Hauppauge (2 shops, about 4 miles), Deer Park (2 shops, about 6 miles), and Nesconset (1 shop, about 7 miles). 2 of the 4 listings link out to a website of their own; where a field is missing from a record we leave it blank rather than guess at it. Nothing here records stock, prices or event nights — those fields do not exist in the dataset. For what to look for once you are through the door, see the guide to finding a good card shop or the card collecting starter guide.