Card Shops in Cicero, New York

Cicero, New York has 2 card shops in our directory — 1 is filed under trading card games and 1 under sports cards. Every listing has an address and a Google Maps link; 2 of 2 also have a phone number and 2 have posted hours.

Of those 2, 1 is an independent shop and 1 is a national chain location. Independents are listed first on this page and the chain entry sits in a collapsed block at the end. For context, New York as a whole carries 253 independent shops in 144 cities alongside 100 chain locations. Small as it is, this page is a real entry rather than a placeholder: it exists because Cicero has at least one independent shop. The 30 New York cities whose only listings are a national chain get a page too, but those are kept out of search results. Within driving range are Clay at roughly 7 miles with 1 shop, Liverpool at roughly 8 miles with 3 shops, and De Witt at roughly 9 miles with 1 shop.

Every one of these 2 shops carries a rating; weighting each rating by how many reviews stand behind it puts Southpaw Sports Cards first, on 4.5 stars across 127 reviews. Websites are patchier than phone numbers here — 1 of 2 has one on file — and a blank field means the source record had nothing, not that the shop lacks one. Nothing here records stock, prices or event nights — those fields do not exist in the dataset. For what to look for once you are through the door, see the guide to finding a good card shop or the card collecting starter guide.