Card Shops in Amityville, New York

Amityville, New York has 2 card shops in our directory — 2 are filed under sports cards. Every listing has an address and a Google Maps link; 2 of 2 also have a phone number and 2 have posted hours.

All 2 listings are independent — no national chain location in Amityville is on file. Ratings exist for 1 of these 2 shops; weighting each rating by how many reviews stand behind it puts SMR Collectibles | We Buy Sports Cards | We Buy Sports Memorabilia | We Sell Sports Cards first, on 4.2 stars across 65 reviews. A page this short still earns a place in the index because the listing on it is an independent shop. Elsewhere in New York, 30 cities have nothing but chain locations, and those pages are marked to stay out of search results. Ranked by independent count, Amityville is 20th of the 144 New York cities that have an independent shop on file. Websites are patchier than phone numbers here — 1 of 2 has one on file — and a blank field means the source record had nothing, not that the shop lacks one.

Looking at the 2 posted schedules here: 2 close on Sundays. For context, New York as a whole carries 253 independent shops in 144 cities alongside 100 chain locations. Within driving range are Lindenhurst at roughly 2 miles with 1 shop, Massapequa at roughly 2 miles with 1 shop, and West Babylon at roughly 4 miles with 1 shop. Stock, buy prices and event schedules are outside what this directory tracks, so call ahead for anything specific. The shop-finding guide and the starter guide cover the questions worth asking.