
Hours of Operation
Location & Contact
About This Listing
Fan Cave is recorded at 4805 Madison Ave in Indianapolis, IN 46227. If Indianapolis comes up short, Speedway (1 shop, ~7 mi) and Carmel (~12 mi) are the nearest alternatives on file. Two other listings sit close by: The Card Depot, under a mile off, and Grandmaster Games at under a mile. Indiana as a whole has 191 independent shops on file across 86 cities and 52 chain locations alongside them. Classification here is sports cards — a directory-level label drawn from the business listing rather than from a stock check. Its 4.4-star Google rating rests on 124 reviews, the 19th-largest review count of the 27 rated listings in Indianapolis.
The widest the posted week gets is 10 AM at one end and 5:30 PM at the other. Both a phone number and a website are on file, which puts this listing among the 26 of 29 in Indianapolis that link out to a site of their own. Hours are posted for 6 of the seven days; Sunday is marked closed. On the Indianapolis page, which lists 29 shops (23 independent, 6 chain), this listing sits 15th. That order is a rating weighted by review count, not alphabetical and not by distance. Stock is the one thing this page cannot tell you — the dataset has no inventory, pricing or event fields for any shop. Ring ahead if you are making a trip for something specific.
About Fan Cave
Sports card shop located in Indianapolis, IN. Rated 4.4/5 stars.
Collector Notes
Fan Cave is a sports card shop in Indianapolis, IN. Visitors rate the shop 4.4 stars across 124 Google reviews.
Review Summary
Frequently Asked Questions About Fan Cave
When is Fan Cave open?
Fan Cave is open Monday 12 to 5:30 PM, Tuesday 12 to 8 PM, Wednesday 10 AM to 5:30 PM, Thursday 10 AM to 5:30 PM, Friday 10 AM to 5:30 PM, and Saturday 10 AM to 5:30 PM. It is closed Sunday. Hours can change on holidays — call ahead to confirm.
Where is Fan Cave located?
Fan Cave is located at 4805 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227, in Indiana.
What kind of cards does Fan Cave sell?
Fan Cave is listed in this directory as a sports card shop.
Helpful Guides
New to sports cards? These guides cover the basics and what to look for at a local shop.
Something wrong with this listing?
If Fan Cave has closed, moved, or the hours here are out of date, tell us and we'll fix it.
Report a problem Suggest another shop
Own this shop? Upgrade your site — we build card shop websites and hand you the keys, domain included.
Shop Details
Category
Sports Card Shop
Location
Nearby Cities
Closest cities to Indianapolis with card shops in our directory.