Where to Buy Trading Cards in New Castle, Indiana

2 card shops selling Pokemon, sports cards, Magic: The Gathering and more.

Looking for trading cards in New Castle? This page lists every card shop in the city, broken down by category so you can find exactly what you're looking for. Whether you collect Pokemon, play Magic, or chase sports rookies, you'll find the right local shop here.

Each listing includes address, phone, hours, and a direct Google Maps link. Most shops also host weekly tournaments and events — call ahead to confirm.

Trading Card Game (TCG) Shops

1 shop carrying Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and other TCGs in New Castle.

Sports Card Shops

1 shop carrying baseball, basketball, football, and hockey cards in New Castle.

Other Cities in Indiana

Indianapolis (16)Fort Wayne (10)Evansville (10)Muncie (8)Lafayette (5)Noblesville (5)Terre Haute (4)Columbus (4)